Topic RSS
11:22 pm
September 5, 2014
Offlinemystarryeyes said
@ Adam: Once you become more sure-footed and confident as a writer, you'll be better able to take heed of advice you consider useful and disregard the rest.
Alright, I look forward to the journey of getting there!
1:01 am
September 2, 2014
OfflineHey Adam, finally have time to breakdown your lyrics and explain some things in detail. I understand you're not changing these and I think you made a great decision to just put this out there as is. But this will help show you the process to edit future lyrics. This breakdown is not a definite process, just my way of nitpciky critiquing, and you can kinda sort of do it on yourself if you ever want to, but mostly, it just gives you more to think about.
First of all, holy shit I wrote up a storm. My apologies. I'm sick and typing is perfect for my current energy level LOL so i just went all in.
The main thing you would want to check for is cliches and ways of saying them differently and saying something more meaningful.
Verse 1
Life is for the living (cliche) - ask yourself WHY is life worth living in order to go deeper
Don't worry just keep giving - not a cliche, but you can do better - perhaps explain WHY not to worry (but don't TELL us, SHOW with imagery, simile, etc...paint the picture)
The present keeps falling into the past - this line by itself doesn't really carry the meaning it should until we hear the next line. often that is okay but just CONSIDER rewording these lines
We can't hold on to it, it's moving too fast - i like how you mention "can't hold on" - you could try in a simile or metaphor to really make that physical or dive into the touch sense
Realize it's gone, just keep moving on - ask yourself, WHAT does it mean to move on? HOW do we move on? WHY is it hard to move on? write about that
Cause there's really nothing that can be done. - yes there is.
explain this. again, don't TELL or "preach", just show us...give us a scene...invite us into your movie, your novel
Chorus
Cause the past is history
And the future is a mystery - past is history is a cliche, but i think the way you followed up with this new phrase (unless it's a cliche too? i don't think so) ties in to make it brilliant
But now is a gift - "now is a gift" - I'm not sure if that's grammatically perfect and everything, but I love it. I think everybody intuitively understands this use of "Now" as a noun, a thing...
That's why we call it the present - this pun made me smile, but perhaps it was a bit too lighthearted for the song. unless you want a lighthearted song, then make it obvious that way from start to finish. but i think you have such a deeper message in here that you need to present (hehe) it more deeply.
First of all before we go into the second verse I have to admit I barely remember hearing it after listening to this song a few times through. That is NOT a good thing. One thing I could address is that it may have helped to match lines 1 and 2 rhythmically to lines 1 and 2 of the first verse, so there is something common to latch onto.
Also I suspect that trying to rhyme the first and second lines of your verses and so quickly, may have sabotaged the opportunity to really start them off strong in terms of what is expressed. If I were you I think I would have just put one longer line there instead of two that connect.
Verse 2
Whatever will be - you phrased this too quickly for it to register meaningfully especially as it is a short and kind of awkward sentence. i would recommend, maybe drop the rhyme and say "whatever will happen" or a similar word to happen (looking up synonyms is your friend)
We just can't see - you could leave it like this, but it is a common superficial lyric and you could go deeper if you want - maybe talk about being blind to it, blind faith, make an imagery of fog blocking something (i'm just throwing out random ideas)
Live in the moment and you'll always be free - these are kind of cliches, but the connection between them is good and the way you sang them really jumps out making this the highlight of your verse. but lines 1 and 2 need that kind of strength too, lyrically and/or in the vocal delivery.
What you do now will determine your reality - my first reaction to this line is "no shit" - try not to state the obvious in a lyric, ever! I would ask you, what are you really trying to say when you put that in there? If someone asked you "explain that lyric" - explore that elaboration to help you figure out what you really meant, and then once you've found THAT, maybe try throwing Phil's exercise at it to turn it from telling that message deeper into SHOWING it deeper.
So get up and go - "what you do now" and "get up and go" - the rhythm you sang is too short and takes the emphasis away from what you are saying. pick a rhythm that is similar to how you would phrase it if you just speak the words.
Stop trying and start doing what you know - good lyric. others might call it preachy but I am not too sensitive to that stuff so i am not the person to ask. i just like it because it is to the point of what you're trying to convey, not a cliche, and it makes me THINK.
Bridge
The moment you realize it - realize WHAT? if you want it general, maybe take out "it"? but that's funky too - plus you already said realize in your verse - consider a synonym or rewording
The moment's already gone
That's why I keep moving on - you already said moving on in your first verse! Another rule of thumb, generally, try not to repeat yourself in a lyric outside of the chorus.
That's what I do as I sing this song - cliche and a half! We know you are singing and writing songs to deliver a message, you don't have to tell us. This might be another example of where the rhyme is sabotaging you and leading you to write a lyric that doesn't really mean anything.
Dealing with whatever I control - I would personally change it it to "whatever I can control"
Leaving the rest up to my soul - this and the line before it, killer.
Whatever has been and whatever will be - repeating yourself again but this is where you SHOULD say whatever will be because it fits more smoothly in the sentence. Then you would just replace the first lines in the second verse.
I'll just let it flow - YES! great line and perfect placement - the end of a bridge is a great place for a lyric like this that has extra power - in this case, this simple feeling of letting go and outpouring, surrendering to what happens...but you're using a less common, but still universally understood verb to say that...brilliant. On top of all that, the way you dropped out the music behind it is very effective.
In summary, the things for you to focus on are:
In the earlier stages of writing a song:
Do lyric exercises and general creative writing exercises on a frequent basis. Phil and I mentioned some good ones and there are many many others. They don't all have to make their way into actual songs, I think simply doing them will improve your lyrics naturally.
Explore metaphor, simile, imagery, and all the senses.
Focus on SHOWING not TELLING (hopefully that makes sense, let me know if I should try to explain further). But writing out in telling first can be a cool avenue to discovering and focusing what you want to show.
In the later stages:
Inwardly ask yourself who, what, when, where, why, how incessantly, and answer through your lyric. Not every song answers them all, but think of it like:
-why, how, and what relate to your argument. a message song like this needs these answered very well.
-who, when, where relate to the setting. not as applicable for this song and are kind of more tricky to convey gracefully (I'm still not good at it) but great lyricists do often answer them, especially right in the top of the first verse, just like a book introduces its setting very early.
Go back and make sure every single line is strong, or pairs of lines - you seem to do nicely with pairing two short lines together to make a good point so maybe play to that strength but you don't want to rely on it as a crutch either.
Don't be afraid to look up synonyms and rhymes whenever you feel it could help.
Take care not to get preachy. Encouraging may be a better way to go about it and it's again rooted in showing not telling.
That's a nice segway to a recommendation for a great lyric I discovered recently that I think you should check out for influence/inspiration/guidance - Village Ghetto Land by Stevie Wonder, lyrics written by Gary Byrd. Excellent example of delivering a strong message but in a way that's encouraging, not pushy, just makes us think, and encapsulates the listener into what is going on through showing not telling. Check out his use of words and language too, really neat and clever stuff, some of it we have terms for (lots of imagery, i saw a line with personification too), some of it I'm not so sure, but try to think hard about how he came up with what he did and that will teach you a lot.
Cheers Adam, and if any of this seems over your head just take it with a grain of salt. Maybe copy and save this post and come back to it periodically. I feel like I am revealing what I learned slowly over many years all at once and I'm not sure how quickly one can handle all of it.
My original music:
https://soundcloud.com/owen-korzec
https://www.facebook.com/owenkorzec
All kinds of stuff:
https://www.youtube.com/user/owenkorzec
11:01 am
September 5, 2014
OfflineI am definitely going to save this. This is an awesome critique with lots to digest. I agree that it will take time because there is a lot here. I look forward to hearing your thoughts on my next song.
11:40 am
September 2, 2014
OfflineGlad to hear that was helpful! 
My original music:
https://soundcloud.com/owen-korzec
https://www.facebook.com/owenkorzec
All kinds of stuff:
https://www.youtube.com/user/owenkorzec
Most Users Ever Online: 607
Currently Online:
19 Guest(s)
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
OwenKorzec: 283
TommyTheHat: 186
quentin: 138
Adam Mishan: 84
wabba_treads420: 72
Sexy Beast: 60
daniel formica: 59
IAm: 48
Slow Start: 34
Mivke: 31
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 0
Members: 223
Moderators: 0
Admins: 3
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 6
Topics: 331
Posts: 1860
Newest Members:
steviedee, Mitch, carol, fabriciofreitag, owow, alex 5, SusiKette, Student Teacher, Michael, StevenSAdministrators: Marnell Sample: 45, Phil Moufarrege: 264, Felipe Carvalho: 117

Log In
Forum